Get Posts by E-mail

There’s nothing in this world more fun to teach than proportional reasoning. I mean, if you can’t make magic out of proportions, check yourself into math teacher rehab or something, ’cause you’re missing the view.

13 Responses to “We Can All Agree On This, Right?”

  1. on 12 Oct 2008 at 10:27 amJackie Ballarini

    Oh, that picture made me immediately think of sampling methods. I’ve done capture-recapture with beans. I did not know they made colored goldfish crackers. Nice!

  2. on 12 Oct 2008 at 11:11 amdan

    This is why you’re my blogroll buddy.

  3. on 12 Oct 2008 at 12:35 pmLouise Maine

    I agree. I am not a math teacher. I am a Biology teacher. Nothing is more fun to see if they get it by having them reason out the size of a microscope field of view in high power if we know the field of view in low power (and all the magnifications). It can’t be seen so one has to rely on logic.

  4. on 12 Oct 2008 at 3:07 pmJake

    Back in the day my mentor teacher did this activity with Blow Pops. Definitely a hit with the kids, and no talking while you debrief the activity. I wonder if he still does that activity…

    Most schools are No Candy Zones these days, so no one can use this idea.

  5. on 12 Oct 2008 at 7:14 pmBrian Cormier

    All right. So, what are the best ideas for teaching proportional reasoning? I think I do a good job, but magic? Not so sure. I don’t want to be sent to rehab without a fight.

  6. on 12 Oct 2008 at 8:03 pmdebrennersmith

    This is great! I showed this to my two teens tonight. They “played” at it for over 45 minutes since it was not real homework. I appreciate the ideas.

  7. on 12 Oct 2008 at 8:39 pmEmilie

    How does this “game” work? I’m wondering if I could adapt it to teaching the balancing of chemical equations to my students….

  8. on 13 Oct 2008 at 6:48 amCliff

    This was the best activity I have ever done, period. I even got observed during one class and my administrator loved it.
    There’s a great video on unitedstreaming about how the capture/recapture method works that I played prior to the activity.

    Thanks Dan, I just discovered your blog and it’s nice to know someone is out there on the same plane. I even feel your pain on burning the midnight oil coming up with powerpoints (older post). It was totally worth it in year two, except the kids still didn’t care (for the most part). Although it did help with management a little, they just want to be entertained, not taught. Do you find a big impact on the atmosphere when you use those slides?

    Now I have moved to a different school that was supposedly more upscale and I don’t even have a classroom and they have hardly any technology to use!!

  9. on 13 Oct 2008 at 9:05 amBrian Cormier

    Maybe I missed something, but what activity are we talking about? Did I miss a link, or is the goldfish picture an obvious reminder of a universally known proportions activity?

  10. on 13 Oct 2008 at 11:11 amdan

    Nah, I think some of us are on different tangents here. Here’s a fair approximation of the activity.

  11. on 13 Oct 2008 at 1:50 pmKate

    I’ve done it by marking dried beans with a sharpie – nice activity…the colored goldfish crackers are a cute idea. Once they get it we play a little game called “How many kids in this school….” (have a dog, don’t have a lunch period, were born in another country, have divorced parents, etc etc) using the class as the sample representing the school – attendant discussions of how reliable those numbers are – big fun.

  12. on 14 Oct 2008 at 8:27 amJason Dyer

    Our classroom is not just a no-candy zone but a no-food zone. So I’ve never been able to try this one. (The lesson plan I have involves M&Ms.)

  13. on 14 Oct 2008 at 8:51 pmChuck

    Here’s my dilemma – I can’t think of one professional development/workshop/conference I’ve attended in the first 15 months of teaching that informs my curriculum even a shred as much as one post like this does…As a side note, I love this blog and the talent surrounding it. I bet that if this community could put together a conference, I might leave with some actual ideas for contextualizing algebra 2.

    How good does that sound – a conference of good, creative teachers…sharing ideas for curriculum and structures. I swear I’m too young to this profession to be such, but each hour I spend in “professional development” or working towards my credential when I know my time be better used to plan a good lesson makes me feel just a bit more jaded.

    Can anyone help on finding honestly beneficial ‘professional development’? I have a reasonable administration, but they can’t help me teach math…